A Roman Catholic priest accused of impregnating a Cree girl at a residential school in northern Manitoba in the 1940s was known in the area as a predator to multiple girls and women.

Randal Apetagon’s hands shake as he holds a nearly 100-year-old portrait of a Roman Catholic priest. The man’s eyes are familiar. Apetagon’s mom had the same stare. “It sends chills right down my spine,” he said. “Feels like seeing a ghost.